The Principles Behind Attitude Training.
I honestly had the fear that, if I were to try to train their emotions, the kids would just bottle everything up and stuff it down and eventually go on a bender or a rampage as adults. If I were to attempt to train their emotions, I would be committing the sin of 'not reaching their hearts'. I think it's a common fear parents have in our current culture. But I felt so stuck, because the moodiness was controlling our home and our relationships. So I started to think about what the Bible has to say about emotions.
What I noticed is that, while the Bible doesn't necessarily command us to feel certain ways, it does command us to adopt certain attitudes - to make choices based on right thinking, which leads to right acting, which, funnily enough, has implications for our emotions. Feeling happy and being joyful are two different things. God doesn't tell us to feel happy. But he does - often - tell us to be joyful, even in less-than-happy circumstances. In fact, most of the fruits of the Spirit are attitudes. And if God desires it, and commands it, and wants to foster it in us, then we should value it enough to try to train our kids in those paths.
I started teaching the kids that their attitudes are not enslaved to their emotions, as we tend to assume they are, but rather their emotions are chained to their attitudes. When we choose cheerfulness, even when doing a job we really don't like, we actually tend to start feeling more cheerful. When we choose kindness, even when we feel annoyed with a sibling, we tend to start feeling more kind. Right thinking and right action (in other words, right attitude) lead to positive emotions.
It doesn't mean that we squash their feelings, or teach them to bottle everything up, but it does place a higher value on reveling in feelings that correspond with truth. And I think that's why 'self-control' is the last mentioned fruit of the Spirit, after a long list of attitudes. If a child can realize they're in control of their own self, emotions and all, love will be easier. Joy will be easier. Peace, patience, and kindness will be easier. In other words, any good, enjoyable work that the Spirit wishes to do in their hearts will be met with so much more cooperation in a person who has self-control: control over their whole self.
The more I've talked with the kids about this, and corrected wrong attitudes when they've arisen, the more amazed I am at how God knows what he's talking about in this area. (Shocker!) I can't command my kids to feel happy when they're told to clean their rooms. That's pointless and unhelpful, as I don't have the right or authority to tell them 'just feel differently.' But I can address their grumbling and disrespect when they don't want to clean their rooms - I can talk to them about why grumbling is such an affront to God, and how he wants us to respond instead. I can model for them an appropriate response, and practice with them over and over until they respond cheerfully. And I can cheer them on when, time after time, a cheerful response leads to a real feeling of happiness.
The Practical How-To's of Attitude Training.
It has really worked wonders with all of my kids, but one of them specifically is just thriving since I've started being diligent about training them in this area. This kiddo is given to moodiness and a melancholy disposition a lot of the time. Teaching them that they (not their feelings) are in charge of their responses, has really lit a fire in them to exercise power over their moods. It has been so great for all of us - for me, because I feel a cloud lifting from our daily life, and for this kiddo because I think they feel 'in charge' of themselves for the first time! They don't feel constantly tossed around all day long. To be honest, this kid is so much happier. Attitude training has helped them feel better.
One thing that has really helped in all of this (beyond LOTS of talking about heart attitudes) is practicing with them. If a kid is grumbly, I'll take them aside and say, "No, that's a grumbly response. Let's try it again with a cheerful attitude. Let's un-scowl our eyebrows first - lift them high, like this! Then we're going to wiggle the scowls out of our bodies - wiggle! Relax! Then we're going to respond in a cheerful voice, so put the scowly voice away. I'm going to tell you again to clean your room, and I want you to respond rightly this time. I'll show you - listen to how I say it: 'Okay, Mom!'"
The older kids are better able to master acting one way while hanging on to the grumbles on the inside, which is not what I'm going for. I want to teach them to be truly experiencing heart change, not just giving me lip service. So talking takes longer, but they're really responsive to reason. "I understand why that was frustrating to you. Your brother said something unkind and untrue, and I will definitely address those things with him. But do you see how your anger is stemming from a place of feeling like you're owed a good name? If you know that what he said isn't true of you, why are you angry? If you have a clean conscience in this area, what does it matter if his opinion of you feels unfair or unkind? God knows your heart, and he knows what's true. He will vindicate you, and will protect your reputation. But you're acting like that's not enough. Your desire to control your brother, and his opinion of you, is stirring up anger in your heart, and that anger is causing you to sin - you are failing to treat your brother with kindness because of your anger. Take a breath, remember what's true, and together we'll think of a way for you to show kindness to him, even though you feel angry right now."
I know that it's controversial these days to act like we ought to train anything beyond our kids' behaviors. They should be allowed to feel all their feelings without shame or guilt! I would say that our kids' feelings, while they are a very real part of them, can be enslaving - and how is it a kindness to them to not teach them that THEY are in charge of how they act, not their feelings? How is it a kindness to let them grow to adulthood without learning that they don't have to live at the whims of their fickle emotions? I know there are many days in my own life that would have gone much better if I had been in charge, rather than whatever feeling decided to show up that day. My words would have been kinder, my disposition would have been more peaceful, and my focus would have been less self-centric.
Our kids will reap so many benefits if we put the hard work into teaching these things to them now!
For more on the topic of feelings, and an example of how this training has looked in our family, don't miss this post: Your Feelings are Real, but They Can Be Liars.
















































